When Good Ideas Go Bad

I carry a little Molskine notebook around with me, most of the time. I jot down phrases, story ideas, random thoughts, and even the occasional bits of a poem or lyric. The pocket-sized volume is very important to me. It holds a lot of the ingredients that are constantly simmering in my creative mind.

Another thing I will write in the notebook: Blog ideas.

Last week I made several quick entries of topics I wanted to blog about. This week, I attempted to write those blog posts. Without success.

I tried several times. Started three times, just yesterday. But none of those attempts “took” and I was reminded: Sometimes good ideas go bad.

This is true in all kinds of writing: blogs, fiction, non-fiction, poetry. If you’ve ever been really excited by the concept of a movie and then walked out of the theater with glazed eyes and a headache, you know it happens in script writing.

When you have a good idea for a writing topic, it can be very frustrating when the words won’t come.

A good idea is only one part of writing. It’s only a MINOR part of writing. I heard someone say once, “I would rather read a boring topic written well than a brilliant topic poorly written.” (I may have also heard someone say the exact opposite, but with less panache…)

Sometimes, a good idea isn’t enough to get the creative engine running. That’s a frustrating thing, though. It’s one thing to stare at a blank page for hours when you’ve “got nothing.” It’s much worse to have the idea, but fail to find the words you are looking for to flesh the idea into reality.

There are two things I took away from this experience, though:

1) Some people would call this “writer’s block” – But, I’ve not been blocked in other areas the last two days. I would say I’m blocked when it comes to writing those two blog posts, but I’ve accomplished other writing tasks. Ultimately, this may be the way I best deal with the idea of writer’s block: I have multiple things I can work on, and if I get stuck in one place, I can focus somewhere else.

2) My little notebook – It’s more than just a temporary holder of ideas. It is part of a larger archival strategy. Whatever good idea isn’t working today, may work later. A story idea that sputters and stalls out today, may leap off the page next year. As writers, we are often told to “kill our darlings” when it comes to passages we are too in love with but which weigh a story down. Some people even say we should get rid of good ideas that seem to go bad; they aren’t worth our time if they don’t come freely. But I tend to exile my darlings, not kill them. They may be pulled from a story, or not written about on the blog, but they aren’t thrown away. I have notebooks and an odds-and-ends computer file where these little snippets dawdle until I’m ready for them. When I’m really feeling like I don’t have anything to write about, I will look through all these bits and pieces and see if anything is triggered. It almost always works.

So, maybe I shouldn’t call it a bad idea. Let’s call her, misunderstood.

photo credit: Alex Bellink via photo pin cc

Advertisements

5 thoughts on “When Good Ideas Go Bad

    • I was particularly fond of the “Darlings in Exile” bit, to be honest. I surprised myself with that one….haha. But “misunderstood ideas” isn’t bad either.

      The Molskine is essential. It gets filled quickly with jibberish, and soon looks like it’s been in a boxing match with an over-sized opponent.

      • Mine are also filled with jibberish. Either that or my 2 year old daughter gets a hold of it and draws circles in it calling them cookies. Super cute.

        She once used white crayon on almost every page and when I met with an agent for my novel I almost couldn’t find a page to write anything down! Well, gotta start young I suppose.

  1. I have a little notebook that goes with me everywhere. I usually just got down information, observations and story ideas. I tend to use my iPad for my blogging ideas. Perhaps I’m missing a great opportunity here as I don’t tend to think about blog ideas when I’m out and about….perhaps I should 😉

    Xx

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s